Ik deelde deze online quiz ook al op mijn Engelstalige blog, en doe het ook maar even hier omdat ik via de verschillende sociale platformen behoorlijk wat reactie kreeg. Het is een interessante oefening die toont hoe technologie het behoorlijk fout kan hebben. De software wordt zeer veel gebruikt, maar betekent dat ook veel informatie onterecht onbereikbaar is voor leerlingen.

De achtergrond bij deze quiz:

We have built the Red Flag Machine quiz to illustrate the shocking absurdity of GoGuardian’s flagging algorithm. GoGuardian is a student monitoring tool that watches over twenty-seven million students across ten thousand schools. Derived from real GoGuardian data, the quiz presents real websites that were flagged, and the keywords that they were flagged for containing. Visitors are asked to guess what keywords triggered the alert. After each question, they will see what keywords were actually found and flagged on the site, and why we think they were flagged.

The data for the quiz, and our report, comes from dozens of public records requests we filed. Using data from multiple schools in both red and blue states, what we uncovered was that, by design, GoGuardian is a red flag machine—its false positives heavily outweigh its ability to accurately determine whether the content of a site is harmful. This results in tens of thousands of students being flagged for viewing content that is not only benign, but often, educational or informative.

We identified multiple categories of non-explicit content that are regularly marked as harmful or dangerous, including: College application sites and college websites; counseling and therapy sites; sites with information about drug abuse; sites with information about LGBTQ issues; sexual health sites; sites with information about gun violence; sites about historical topics; sites about political parties and figures; medical and health sites; news sites; and general educational sites. Read more of our findings in our report.